Sammy says:

A tragus piercing is more of a uncomfort that pain. It does hurt but only when you first get it done and the noise of the cartilage in that part popping is a little gross. But it isn’t as painful as anything else.
Cartilage is painful at first and kind of like a finger prick. But hurts for a really long time after especially if you bump it or sleep on it.
But I’d go with Tragus – 5
Cartilage – 7
Prices are different depending on jewelry and the piercer.
But if you go to look first they can tell you.
And of course you can get them both at the same time